Is Electrician trying to pull a fast one?

Discussion in 'Electricians' Talk' started by MickW8s, Oct 19, 2016.

  1. MickW8s

    MickW8s New Member

    Short post as I am at work but the job needs to be agreed very quickly or a replacement electrician found.

    Having a full kitchen replacement. Currently have a 3.5Kw built-in oven and a 6Kw induction hob connected to the same supply which connects to a 32A breaker on the consumer unit. Consumer unit is relatively new, but not to the latest spec (not metal). Consumer unit has 2 other 32A breakers in use for sockets, then 16 and 6s.

    New kitchen will have same oven and hob, but they will be on different walls on the layout. Built in microwave will join the oven.

    Electrician says the CU needs replacing with latest spec. Also that oven, hob and microwave need to be on their own distinct supplies. Oven to a 16A breaker, microwave to different 16A breaker and hob to a 32A breaker.

    Prices quoted seem excessive, too. I appreciate they include the work but for the CU and wiring for the 3 appliances, he has quoted £470 + VAT. These tasks are listed as:
    1x16A supply + DP switch for oven
    1x16A supply for micro & DP switch
    New 17th edition DB with 2 RCDs 10xMCBs
    Remove CCU & install 32A CCU for Hob

    Seems that the CCU is sort of getting charged for twice.

    Thanks for any advice.
     
  2. Lectrician

    Lectrician Screwfix Select

    CCU - Cooker Control Unit.
    CU - Consumer Unit.

    I would personally want to see new circuits for the appliances. If the oven was with the hob, a single circuit would be OK, but they are not grouped together, so independent circuits seems sensible.

    No need for a CU change though, you can add circuits to an existing moulded CU as long as there is no signs of overheating, and the terminations are checked for tightness.

    £470 for the work seems reasonable to me, although the CU doesn't require replacing.
     
    leesparkykent likes this.
  3. MickW8s

    MickW8s New Member

    Thanks for the speedy response. Are you saying that £470 is reasonable with the CU change? It should be lower if that part is removed? He's quoted £280+VAT for changing it (as part of the £470 mentioned).
     
  4. Lectrician

    Lectrician Screwfix Select

    £470 is quite cheap for a couple new circuits and the CU.

    If you deduct the £280 he has allowed, that allows less the £200 for the new circuits. Seems too cheap.
     
  5. MickW8s

    MickW8s New Member

    There is other work as well, I just detailed the relative stuff. Maybe he's pricing it more based on the whole job. Do you think I should ask him not to change the CU?
     
  6. Based on what 'Lec says - new CU is not essential - then it's your call whether to have it replaced or not.

    However, please bear in mind that the two main 'parts' of this quote - replace the CU and run new circuits - probably won't individually add up to the (very reasonable) £470. What I mean is, to do each job separately would almost certainly add up to significantly more than the current £470 total. This is because the job 'overlaps' in parts. So it's possible if you say "No new CU, thanks" then the bill won't drop by £280 (unless he has made it clear that he is pricing each thing separately and is happy to split the cost evenly.)

    I mean, £280 for a new CU sounds darned good to me!

    So he could be making it a case of "It costs this much to run your new circuits to your CU and add new MCBs there, but only this much extra to fully replace the CU since I'm already doing work in there..."

    Check with the guy first, as his quotes seems very keen.

    And, as part of a full kitchen refurb - which is likely to be costing a fair whack - this sounds like good value to get yer hoosie up to spec in the CU department. Typical quotes I've seen on here for a CU upgrade are usually in the £400+ bracket, I think? So if you call someone out in a couple of year's time to update your CU, it's gonna cost virtually £ouble your current quote?

    I think I'd be considering this as paying for a new CU - and having the new kitchen circuits thrown in for free! It's a good quote.
     
    Nosher likes this.
  7. unphased

    unphased Screwfix Select

    Too cheap in my opinion. New CU, a decent one, with RCBOs not the usual half-way-house dual RCD, £600.00. Kitchen work another £400. £1000 job. He does not really understand kitchen designs either. The oven and hob can be connected to the same 32A cooker circuit. There is no need to have a microwave oven on its own circuit that's just ridiculous, it gets plugged in to a socket on the kitchen sockets circuit. You get what you pay for. It really makes me annoyed to see the drivvle that so called electricians spout to their customers and the stupid prices they charge.
     
    FatHands and seneca like this.
  8. Bazza

    Bazza Screwfix Select

    I am 100% in agreement with UP on this. No need for new circuit for hob + oven. That's what a cooker is, isn't it? And diversity applies, so no worries there.

    Small point though, re
    You didn't mention the power requirements for the microwave. Some of the upmarket ones are rated at more than 13A and need a separate feed. But if its got a UK 13A plug, it can be plugged in to an existing socket, no need for extra circuits.
     
  9. candoabitofmoststuff

    candoabitofmoststuff Screwfix Select

    Depending on where the microwave is to be installed, (i.e. it might be "built in"), it might need an isolator of some kind... and it might make sense, depending on layout, for this to be via an independant cct?

    I'ma DIY bod so I'll now get me coat and go!

    Regards,

    Cando
     
  10. Bazza

    Bazza Screwfix Select

    If its a plug in appliance it doesn't need a separate isolator.
     
  11. Comlec

    Comlec Screwfix Select

    The OP has said
    Maybe it is actually easier to supply a new circuit rather than move the existing CCU. If that is the case you have to ask "how the old cooker circuit will be decommissioned"?
     
  12. MickW8s

    MickW8s New Member

    OK, thanks for all the responses. Consensus seems to be that the pricing is not too high, CU doesn't need to be changed but it wouldn't hurt.
     
  13. JP.

    JP. Screwfix Select

    The sparks prices are very keen indeed - will full certification be produced at the end of the job?
     
  14. Lectrician

    Lectrician Screwfix Select

    If the hob and oven are a distance apart, I would much prefer to see a pair of circuits. If you're running a new one for the microwave (fitted microwaves are usually 16-20 amp), then you may as well run two cables.
     
    leesparkykent likes this.
  15. candoabitofmoststuff

    candoabitofmoststuff Screwfix Select

    But if it is "built in" and you can't get to the socket where it's plugged in, don't you need to be able to isolate it via a switch, as you need to be able to de-power it without "unbuilding" it?
    Or is that wrong?

    Regards,
    Cando
     
  16. JP.

    JP. Screwfix Select

    No its not wrong Can - you are embracing the readily accessible isolation reg without circumvention - its the way I fitted mine. My microwave is in a bridging cabinet and it is plugged in - below it is the isolator above the worktop.

    But I suppose just the plug and socket in the cab is enough - but in my regs that is not classed as readily accessible isolation..however this is subject to reg circumvention (reg juggling to be more to the point)
     
  17. unphased

    unphased Screwfix Select

    Hi Cando. It isn't possible to position a socket behind an integrated appliance, there isn't enough room. It is usual in this instance to place the socket inside an adjacent unit so its just a matter of reaching in and pulling out the plug.
     
  18. JP.

    JP. Screwfix Select

    There is plenty of room behind my microwave Un - the socket is just below the top underside of bridging cab and there is plenty of room between the microwave back and socket..granted though other types of appliances might be tight..depends on what type of cabs you are using I suppose. I only fit Ikea and this negates that ''awful service void'' where cables hang and get dusty and greasy and stuff. Yuk.
     
  19. leesparkykent

    leesparkykent Well-Known Member

    I think Lectrician posts are spot on and I agree.
     
  20. Sparkielev

    Sparkielev Screwfix Select

    Def better on separate circuits I just done kitchen, oven hob microwave on separate circuits he very cheap though but without seeing job it hard to judge
     

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice