Mdf Versus Ply

Discussion in 'Carpenters' Talk' started by EddietheEagle, Aug 26, 2015.

  1. EddietheEagle

    EddietheEagle New Member

    Evening all,

    I am building 5 wardrobes 600 deep x 1200 wide x 2320 high. The doors are going to be 600mm wide x 2320 high but split, the bottom being 600 wide x 1450 high and then 600 x 720 the excess being taken up by plinth and head filler.

    I am using Moisture Resistance MDF for all of it 18mm for the carcass and 25mm? For the doors. The doors will be hung off of Kitchen door hinges.

    I was thinking of using 18mm for the doors but am concerned that the doors will warp whereas using 25mm I think it would be less likely, what do you think?

    Secondly, 18mm on the sides, I am concerned that the plates for the kitchen door hinges over time will pull out, whereas, if I used WBP hardwood ply for the sides it would be unlikely to happen, please can I have your thoughts on all of this please,

    Thank you
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 3, 2015
  2. chippie244

    chippie244 Super Member

    18mm MDF will be fine.
    The hinges you want are called 35mm concealed hinges often called Blum hinges after a major manufacter of them.
    If you go on the Blum or Hafele, a supplier, website there should be a chart showing how hinges you will need for the size of door, probably 3 for the larger size and 2 for the smaller.
    You need to decide wether you want the doors to cover the carcass, which is the most common method, if you want the doors to sit inside the carcass or if you want a frame in front of the carcass and the doors to sit inside this.
    When you paint the doors you must paint both sides in fairly quick succession to avoid warping.
     
    vivaro man and FatHands like this.
  3. dwlondon

    dwlondon Active Member

    25mm will be too heavy for an overlaid door. You would need extra blums to take the weight. I use 25mm in a jointed and framed door, set in a face frame. But I assume you are not set up for that type of thing.

    In general mdf should come straight and true thoughout, so long as it has been handled and stored well. But you do get some which can have a slight bow. Which would be noticeable on the bigger doors. In which case have the bowing in the middle facing out, and if it needs it; it can be straightened out with a catch at the centre. Quite often mdf will straighten out nicely with painting.

    If the cabinets are side by side they will have enough for the screws to bite into and hold the blum hinges. Blums have a lot of adjustment and if you get the basic siting about right the doors can be tweaked into place thereafter.

    I have not used ply for a long time in such things. Its nicer to work with. But I think having two different materials means a noticeable difference in the finishes, or more time and effort in achieving a consistent finish.
     
    Last edited: Aug 27, 2015
    FatHands likes this.
  4. I agree with the above - 25mm will be very heavy and is simply not required.

    IF the MDF starts off flat and IF you paint both sides equally as Chips says, then it should remain flat. Especially if you are using moisture-resistant stuff.

    Wear a dust mask... Really.
     
    FatHands likes this.
  5. EddietheEagle

    EddietheEagle New Member

    Thanks all, the whole lots being done with 18mm MR mdf, thanks for your help.
    Other than this, I find the best screw for fixing mdf through the edges to get a good pull and not splitting it are plasterboard screws "the black ones" I also use glue and biscuits. Anybody have any success with any other type of screw?
     
  6. FatHands

    FatHands Well-Known Member

    Sorry if this is a dull question, but what is the bit about being painted at the same time got to do with being flat?
     
  7. parahandy

    parahandy Screwfix Select

    So that's what this is for...
    [​IMG]
     
    malkie129 likes this.
  8. DIYDave.

    DIYDave. Screwfix Select

    Hi Fats;
    I think the point about painting both sides at the same time or in quick succession is to stop the MDF from warping

    Not a problem with a fixed panel that is say screwed to a wall or a carcass, but with a door, painting just one side may cause the board to warp. Painting both sides seems to equalise the warping and you end up with a flat board

    Maybe not the most scientific of explanations from me but in lay mans terms, it seems to work :)

    I assume that para is being humorous above :rolleyes:
     
  9. goldenboy

    goldenboy Super Member

    Drywall screws are not the best for MDF. They are best for fixing plasterboard. Use the Spax MDF screws.
     
  10. EddietheEagle

    EddietheEagle New Member

    Cheers Goldenboy,

    From now on I will use Spax Mdf screws, didn't know there was such a thing!!!!
     
  11. vivaro man

    vivaro man Active Member

    Ed,
    You have some excellent advice here. I would just add that wearing a dustmask as someone has said is mandatory but do not attempt to cut the mdf in an enclosed space without proper dust extraction and ventilation. Mdf is terrible stuff and will cause you problems.
     
  12. malkie129

    malkie129 Screwfix Select

    I can only concur with VM. I've always cut MDF outside. ;)
     
  13. sospan

    sospan Screwfix Select

    and a the best face shield you can afford.

    mdf fibre is horrible
     

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice