Selecting cable size according to tabulated cable calculation

Discussion in 'Electricians' Talk' started by MartSpark, Sep 6, 2005.

  1. MartSpark

    MartSpark New Member

    Hi - I need some help with understanding the Regs with regards to selecting cable size when the tabulated cable rating has been worked out after applying the correction factors (It=In/CF's)

    Say a single core cable has thermal insulation surrounding it for most of it's length (method 4), such that Ci=0.5, and is protected by a 20A fuse (not 3036), then:
    It=20/0.5=40A
    now when looking up what cable size is suitable i.e. Table 41D1, should you select the cable size from the Method 4 column (thermal insulation), or the Method 1 column (clipped direct) ?

    Method 1, 40A cable = 6mm sq
    Method 4, 40A cable = 10mm sq

    in Brian Scaddan's book he chooses Method 1, however I've seen more or less the same example done differently in another book by using Method 4 as you might logically think was the way to do it. However - Method 1 would seem to make sense because the cable has already been derated by the calculation ?

    it's confused the hell out of me, which is the right choice ??!!

    many thanks in advance, got my 2381 exam tomoro
     
  2. Wilb

    Wilb New Member

    I think you're confusing method 4 with 'completely surrounded by insulation'.

    I read 523-04 as saying that you either use method 4 (in contact with thermal conductor on one side) OR you use the derate, applying it against method 1.

    As you say, applying both would be contrary.
     
  3. MartSpark

    MartSpark New Member

    I never knew that - many thanks for making it clear
     

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice