To Nog or Not to Nog ??

Discussion in 'Builders' Talk' started by Welshdragon1, Jan 14, 2015.

  1. Welshdragon1

    Welshdragon1 Active Member

    My Landlord has decided to refurbish the Kitchen & make it bigger by bringing it 1 MTR into the living room, by removing a breeze block wall & replacing it, with a stud wall.

    We are in a ground floor flat with 3 more flats above us, with concrete block ceilings that are wedged with bits of wood which were also used to hold the plasterboard ceiling up.

    The contractors state that as they are using 400 centres & 4" x 2" timbers , there is no need for noggins, not even to fit the kitchen cupboards or over the door & it is not a required standard any more.

    The PSE timbers actually measure out @ 3½" x 1¾"

    I am assuming he meant 400mm centres

    20 odd years ago I was taught to use rough cut timber & place @ least 3 noggins for an 8ft height, staggered a few inches apart to aid fixing the noggins in place .

    Is the contractor correct & has the standards changed, or is he telling porkies, to cut corners ??
     
  2. chippie244

    chippie244 Super Member

    It's your landlords house not yours so it's not your problem.
     
  3. joinerjohn1

    joinerjohn1 Screwfix Select

    Could be his problem if the landlord takes down a breezeblock wall and the neighbour above ends up in his kitchen/living room. ;);););)
     
    Welshdragon1 likes this.
  4. chippie244

    chippie244 Super Member

    Only if he's in it at the time and a lack of noggings will be the least of his problems.
     
    Welshdragon1 likes this.
  5. Jitender

    Jitender Screwfix Select

    Also will need permission from the superior landlord as it is a leasehold property?
     
  6. chippie244

    chippie244 Super Member

    Who said that?
     
  7. Welshdragon1

    Welshdragon1 Active Member

    WOW what a silly thing to say

    That is easy for you to say when your not the one paying the rent & your families lives are not @ potential RISK of INJURY or DEATH from negligence,

    Not to mention the upheaval if one & their family needs to move as a result of cowboy(s)


    Cheers chippy244 :)

    Is there a regulatory body that I can get & print the info off & give to my landlord ??

    Cheers joinerjohn1

    At least the contractor is using Acro's & the block wall does not appear to be load bearing from the holes they made in both sides of the ceiling to verify

    Can you please elaborate, why you have come to that conclusion ??
     
    Last edited: Jan 15, 2015
  8. chippie244

    chippie244 Super Member

    Noggins or no noggings will make little difference to the strength of the wall which will not be structural. If it is structural then that is a different thing.
     
  9. Welshdragon1

    Welshdragon1 Active Member

    Can you educate me further with more info please chippie244
     
  10. joinerjohn1

    joinerjohn1 Screwfix Select

    What chippie means is , if the breezeblock wall is supporting any part of the block floor above (and is removed) the floor above might end up in your living room. (supporting wall means exactly that, it's supporting something, ie structural) If it's replaced with a wooden stud wall, then the stud wall might not be up to supporting what's above (and might still fall down) Don't want to worry you or anything, but I'm assuming your landlord has got proper structural drawings of the property and so knows whether this breezeblock wall is structural? If not then his decision to move it, could be in the lap of the gods.
     
    Welshdragon1 likes this.
  11. chippie244

    chippie244 Super Member

    If the wall that was removed was structural a structural engineer should have been called in to calculate the steel beam required and it's supports, if it's not structural then there's not a problem.
     
    Welshdragon1 likes this.
  12. chippie244

    chippie244 Super Member

    It does sound like they are guessing though by the use of acro's and inspection holes but a lack of noggins is still the least of your worries.
     
  13. Welshdragon1

    Welshdragon1 Active Member

    TBH They didn't have a clue, hence the holes in the ceiling to check, they did discuss the possibility of calling in a structural engineer to check & verify (didn't hear if the had consulted one though) even though they were nearly a week between making the inspection holes & putting the Acro's up.

    Guessing games & the lap of the gods is not my cup of tea tbh especially when it could potentially have disastrous circumstances.

    I will see how it goes as at least I will be around whilst they do the refurb
     
  14. chippie244

    chippie244 Super Member

    If it's not structural there is no need for acro's.
     
  15. Welshdragon1

    Welshdragon1 Active Member

    Personally I do not think it is structural from looking myself, as there is a gap of approx max of 5mm in places 2 - 3mm other places between the block wall & the ceiling (But I could be wrong) though
     
  16. moppylhd

    moppylhd Member

    Have you tried looking into the flat above to see if there is a wall above yours. Also check the direction of the ceiling joists. If running in the same direction as the wall it should be ok. If at right angles, you need to check to see if the wall is supporting any joist joins.
    If your ceilings are concrete, (you say " with concrete block ceilings that are wedged with bits of wood which were also used to hold the plasterboard ceiling up."), there should be no problem.
    I would certainly fit noggins for the top cupboards to fix to. If there is a door going in, certainly noggin this for strength.
    While you're at it check for, self closing fire door with intumescent strips and fireline plasterboard.
     
  17. Welshdragon1

    Welshdragon1 Active Member

    Hi moppylhd

    All the flats above have the walls on top of the walls in the floor(s) below with a concrete floors inbetween, so no joists.

    I managed to have a word with the contractor, without the Landlord up his rear orriface, & he said he will be putting in noggings, but won't be telling the Landlord, since the Landlord wants to cut costs, but doesn't realise that the contractor has already factored it into the price :)

    I will check when I see him on Monday for the "self closing fire door with intumescent strips and fireline plasterboard"

    Is that a formal requirement or Regulation ??
     
  18. Your landlord is trying to cut costs by not having noggins...?

    Bludy hell.

    They need taking out and having their nuts stapled to something not very nice.

    What is it about penny-pinching lardlords, eh? Jeeeeez...
     

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice